In Defense of Women quotes
The lines readers remember from In Defense of Women, by H. L. Mencken.
62 quotes · About the book
Standout lines
A man’s women folk, whatever their outward show of respect for his merit and authority, always regard him secretly as an ass, and with something akin to pity.
Show the passage
A man’s women folk, whatever their outward show of respect for his merit and authority, always regard him secretly as an ass, and with something akin to pity.
His most gaudy sayings and doings seldom deceive them; they see the actual man within, and know him for a shallow and pathetic fellow.
But she never envies him his puerile ego; she never envies him his shoddy and preposterous soul.
Show the passage
She may envy him his masculine liberty of movement and occupation, his impenetrable complacency, his peasant-like delight in petty vices, his capacity for hiding the harsh face of reality behind the cloak of romanticism, his general innocence and childishness.
But she never envies him his puerile ego; she never envies him his shoddy and preposterous soul.
This shrewd perception of masculine bombast and make-believe, this acute understanding of man as the eternal tragic comedian, is at the bottom of that compassionate irony which paces under the name of the maternal instinct.
The truth is that neither sex, without some fertilization by the complementary characters of the other, is capable of the highest reaches of human endeavour.
Show the passage
In women of genius we see the opposite picture. They are commonly distinctly mannish, and shave as well as shine. Think of George Sand, Catherine the Great, Elizabeth of England, Rosa Bonheur, Teresa Carreo or Cosima Wagner.
The truth is that neither sex, without some fertilization by the complementary characters of the other, is capable of the highest reaches of human endeavour.
Man, without a saving touch of woman in him, is too doltish, too naive and romantic, too easily deluded and lulled to sleep by his imagination to be anything above a cavalryman, a theologian or a bank director.
They see at a glance what most men could not see with searchlights and telescopes; they are at grips with the essentials of a problem before men have finished debating its mere externals.
Show the passage
Women decide the larger questions of life correctly and quickly, not because they are lucky guessers, not because they are divinely inspired, not because they practise a magic inherited from savagery, but simply and solely because they have sense.
They see at a glance what most men could not see with searchlights and telescopes; they are at grips with the essentials of a problem before men have finished debating its mere externals.
They are the supreme realists of the race. Apparently illogical, they are the possessors of a rare and subtle super-logic. Apparently whimsical, they hang to the truth with a tenacity which carries them through every phase of its incessant, jellylike shifting of form.
The average man is an almost incredible popinjay; he can think of himself only as at the centre of situations.
Show the passage
… the devices described, take refuge behind the sour grapes doctrine that they have never tried, and the latter, having fallen victims, sooth their egoism by arrogating the whole agency to themselves, thus giving it a specious appearance of the volitional, and even of the audacious.
The average man is an almost incredible popinjay; he can think of himself only as at the centre of situations.
All the sordid transactions of his life appear to him, and are depicted in his accounts of them, as feats, successes, proofs of his acumen.
Man is always looking for someone to boast to; woman is always looking for a shoulder to put her head on.
Show the passage
he also enjoys helping her dry her tears. The result is the vast pretence that characterizes the relations of the sexes under civilization—the double pretence of man’s cunning and autonomy and of woman’s dependence and deference.
Man is always looking for someone to boast to; woman is always looking for a shoulder to put her head on.
This feminine affectation, of course, has gradually taken on the force of a fixed habit, and so it has got a certain support, by a familiar process of self-delusion, in reality. The civilized woman inherits that habit as she inherits her cunning.
All quotes
Jump to a chapter
- 1. The Maternal Instinct
- 2. Women’s Intelligence
- 3. The Masculine Bag of Tricks
- 4. Why Women Fail
- 5. The Thing Called Intuition
- 6. How Marriages are Arranged
- 7. The Feminine Attitude
- 8. The Male Beauty
- 9. Men as Aesthetes
- 10. The Process of Delusion
- 11. Biological Considerations
- 12. Honour
- 13. Women and the Emotions
- 15. Mythical Anthropophagi
- 19. The Actual Husband
- 22. Compulsory Marriage
- 24. Intermezzo on Monogamy
- 26. Disparate Unions
- 27. The Charm of Mystery
- 32. The Woman Voter
- 33. A Glance Into the Future
- 35. A Mythical Dare-Devil
- 37. Women as Martyrs
- 40. Piety as a Social Habit
- 42. The Transvaluation of Values
1. The Maternal Instinct
A man’s women folk, whatever their outward show of respect for his merit and authority, always regard him secretly as an ass, and with something akin to pity.
Show the passage
A man’s women folk, whatever their outward show of respect for his merit and authority, always regard him secretly as an ass, and with something akin to pity.
His most gaudy sayings and doings seldom deceive them; they see the actual man within, and know him for a shallow and pathetic fellow.
The appearance, in the normal family circle, is a hero, magnifico, a demigod. The substance is a poor mountebank.
Show the passage
The mark of that so-called intuition is simply a sharp and accurate perception of reality, an habitual immunity to emotional enchantment, a relentless capacity for distinguishing clearly between the appearance and the substance.
The appearance, in the normal family circle, is a hero, magnifico, a demigod. The substance is a poor mountebank.
The proverb that no man is a hero to his valet is obviously of masculine manufacture. It is both insincere and untrue:
The proverb that no man is a hero to his valet is obviously of masculine manufacture.
Show the passage
The appearance, in the normal family circle, is a hero, magnifico, a demigod. The substance is a poor mountebank.
The proverb that no man is a hero to his valet is obviously of masculine manufacture.
It is both insincere and untrue:
But she never envies him his puerile ego; she never envies him his shoddy and preposterous soul.
Show the passage
She may envy him his masculine liberty of movement and occupation, his impenetrable complacency, his peasant-like delight in petty vices, his capacity for hiding the harsh face of reality behind the cloak of romanticism, his general innocence and childishness.
But she never envies him his puerile ego; she never envies him his shoddy and preposterous soul.
This shrewd perception of masculine bombast and make-believe, this acute understanding of man as the eternal tragic comedian, is at the bottom of that compassionate irony which paces under the name of the maternal instinct.
2. Women’s Intelligence
The caveman is all muscles and mush.
Show the passage
Bismarck and Lincoln had it; in Shakespeare, if the Freudians are to be believed, it amounted to downright homosexuality. The essential traits and qualities of the male, the hallmarks of the unpolluted masculine, are at the same time the hall-marks of the Schalskopf.
The caveman is all muscles and mush.
Without a woman to rule him and think for him, he is a truly lamentable spectacle: a baby with whiskers, a rabbit with the frame of an aurochs, a feeble and preposterous caricature of God.
Without a woman to rule him and think for him, he is a truly lamentable spectacle: a baby with whiskers, a rabbit with the frame of an aurochs, a feeble and preposterous caricature of God.
Show the passage
in Shakespeare, if the Freudians are to be believed, it amounted to downright homosexuality. The essential traits and qualities of the male, the hallmarks of the unpolluted masculine, are at the same time the hall-marks of the Schalskopf. The caveman is all muscles and mush.
Without a woman to rule him and think for him, he is a truly lamentable spectacle: a baby with whiskers, a rabbit with the frame of an aurochs, a feeble and preposterous caricature of God.
It would be an easy matter, indeed, to demonstrate that superior talent in man is practically always accompanied by this feminine flavour—that complete masculinity and stupidity are often indistinguishable.
The wholly manly man lacks the wit necessary to give objective form to his soaring and secret dreams, and the wholly womanly woman is apt to be too cynical a creature to dream at all.
Show the passage
Here, as elsewhere in the universe, the best effects are obtained by a mingling of elements.
The wholly manly man lacks the wit necessary to give objective form to his soaring and secret dreams, and the wholly womanly woman is apt to be too cynical a creature to dream at all.
The truth is that neither sex, without some fertilization by the complementary characters of the other, is capable of the highest reaches of human endeavour.
Show the passage
In women of genius we see the opposite picture. They are commonly distinctly mannish, and shave as well as shine. Think of George Sand, Catherine the Great, Elizabeth of England, Rosa Bonheur, Teresa Carreo or Cosima Wagner.
The truth is that neither sex, without some fertilization by the complementary characters of the other, is capable of the highest reaches of human endeavour.
Man, without a saving touch of woman in him, is too doltish, too naive and romantic, too easily deluded and lulled to sleep by his imagination to be anything above a cavalryman, a theologian or a bank director.
3. The Masculine Bag of Tricks
These were vigorous and masculine men, and in a man’s world they were successful men, but intellectually they were all blank cartridges.
Show the passage
… of another, after a long lifetime in intimate association with some of the chief business “geniuses” of that paradise of traders and usurers, the United States, reported in his old age that he had never heard a single one of them say anything worth hearing.
These were vigorous and masculine men, and in a man’s world they were successful men, but intellectually they were all blank cartridges.
There is, indeed, fair ground for arguing that, if men of that kidney were genuinely intelligent, they would never succeed at their gross and driveling concerns—that their very capacity to master and retain such balderdash as constitutes their stock in trade is proof of their …
4. Why Women Fail
If the work of the average man required half the mental agility and readiness of resource of the work of the average prostitute, the average man would be constantly on the verge of starvation.
Show the passage
In the demimonde one will find enough acumen and daring, and enough resilience in the face of special difficulties, to put the equipment of any exclusively male profession to shame.
If the work of the average man required half the mental agility and readiness of resource of the work of the average prostitute, the average man would be constantly on the verge of starvation.
5. The Thing Called Intuition
Intuition? With all respect, bosh!
Show the passage
It is here that they rise above the insignificant sentimentalities, superstitions and formulae of men, and apply to the business their singular talent for separating the appearance from the substance, and so exercise what is called their intuition.
Intuition? With all respect, bosh!
Then it was intuition that led Darwin to work out the hypothesis of natural selection. Then it was intuition that fabricated the gigantically complex score of “Die Walkure.”
Apparently unobservant and easily deceived, they see with bright and horrible eyes.
Show the passage
They are the supreme realists of the race. Apparently illogical, they are the possessors of a rare and subtle super-logic. Apparently whimsical, they hang to the truth with a tenacity which carries them through every phase of its incessant, jellylike shifting of form.
Apparently unobservant and easily deceived, they see with bright and horrible eyes.
In men, too, the same merciless perspicacity sometimes shows itself—men recognized to be more aloof and uninflammable than the general—men of special talent for the logical—sardonic men, cynics. Men, too, sometimes have brains.
Men, too, sometimes have brains.
Show the passage
Apparently unobservant and easily deceived, they see with bright and horrible eyes. In men, too, the same merciless perspicacity sometimes shows itself—men recognized to be more aloof and uninflammable than the general—men of special talent for the logical—sardonic men, cynics.
Men, too, sometimes have brains.
But that is a rare, rare man, I venture, who is as steadily intelligent, as constantly sound in judgment, as little put off by appearances, as the average women of forty-eight.
Women decide the larger questions of life correctly and quickly, not because they are lucky guessers, not because they are divinely inspired, not because they practise a magic inherited from savagery, but simply and solely because they have sense.
Show the passage
… penetrate to the hidden truth through the most formidable wrappings of false semblance and demeanour, and so little corrupted by sentimental prudery that it is equal to the even more difficult task of hauling that truth out into the light, in all its naked hideousness.
Women decide the larger questions of life correctly and quickly, not because they are lucky guessers, not because they are divinely inspired, not because they practise a magic inherited from savagery, but simply and solely because they have sense.
They see at a glance what most men could not see with searchlights and telescopes; they are at grips with the essentials of a problem before men have finished debating its mere externals. They are the supreme realists of the race.
They see at a glance what most men could not see with searchlights and telescopes; they are at grips with the essentials of a problem before men have finished debating its mere externals.
Show the passage
Women decide the larger questions of life correctly and quickly, not because they are lucky guessers, not because they are divinely inspired, not because they practise a magic inherited from savagery, but simply and solely because they have sense.
They see at a glance what most men could not see with searchlights and telescopes; they are at grips with the essentials of a problem before men have finished debating its mere externals.
They are the supreme realists of the race. Apparently illogical, they are the possessors of a rare and subtle super-logic. Apparently whimsical, they hang to the truth with a tenacity which carries them through every phase of its incessant, jellylike shifting of form.
They are the supreme realists of the race.
Show the passage
They see at a glance what most men could not see with searchlights and telescopes; they are at grips with the essentials of a problem before men have finished debating its mere externals.
They are the supreme realists of the race.
Apparently illogical, they are the possessors of a rare and subtle super-logic. Apparently whimsical, they hang to the truth with a tenacity which carries them through every phase of its incessant, jellylike shifting of form.
6. How Marriages are Arranged
Which side commonly prevails? I leave the verdict to the jury.
Show the passage
The efforts of the two sexes are thus directed, in one of the capital concerns of life, to diametrically antagonistic ends.
Which side commonly prevails? I leave the verdict to the jury.
All normal men fight the thing off; some men are successful for relatively long periods; a few extraordinarily intelligent and courageous men (or perhaps lucky ones) escape altogether.
It makes him, above all, see a glamour of romance in a transaction which, even at its best, contains almost as much gross trafficking, at bottom, as the sale of a mule.
Show the passage
It makes him accept as real the bold play-acting that women always excel at, and at no time more than when stalking a man.
It makes him, above all, see a glamour of romance in a transaction which, even at its best, contains almost as much gross trafficking, at bottom, as the sale of a mule.
A man in full possession of the modest faculties that nature commonly apportions to him is at least far enough above idiocy to realize that marriage is a bargain in which he gets the worse of it, even when, in some detail or other, he …
Save for acts of God, he is forthwith as good as married.
Show the passage
The moment she discerns this sentimentality bubbling within him—that is, the moment his oafish smirks and eye rollings signify that he has achieved the intellectual disaster that is called falling in love—he is hers to do with as she will.
Save for acts of God, he is forthwith as good as married.
He may want company and not intimacy, or intimacy and not company.
Show the passage
He may dream of a beautiful and complaisant mistress, less exigent and mercurial than any a bachelor may hope to discover—and stand aghast at admitting her to his bank-book, his family-tree and his secret ambitions.
He may want company and not intimacy, or intimacy and not company.
He may want a cook and not a partner in his business, or a partner in his business and not a cook.
He may want a cook and not a partner in his business, or a partner in his business and not a cook.
Show the passage
He may want company and not intimacy, or intimacy and not company.
He may want a cook and not a partner in his business, or a partner in his business and not a cook.
But in order to get the precise thing or things that he wants, he has to take a lot of other things that he doesn’t want—that no sane man, in truth, could imaginably want—and it is to the enterprise of forcing him into this almost …
7. The Feminine Attitude
Thus do the ambulant images of God cloak their shackles proudly, and divert the judicious with their boastful shouts.
Show the passage
The sheer horsepower of his wooing has assailed and overcome her maiden modesty; she trembles in his arms; he has been granted a free franchise to work his wicked will upon her.
Thus do the ambulant images of God cloak their shackles proudly, and divert the judicious with their boastful shouts.
Women, it is almost needless to point out, are much more cautious about embracing the conventional hocus-pocus of the situation.
8. The Male Beauty
The voice of their order, the first taboo of their freemasonry, is firmly against making a sentimental debauch of the serious business of marriage.
Show the passage
Women know how little such purely superficial values are worth.
The voice of their order, the first taboo of their freemasonry, is firmly against making a sentimental debauch of the serious business of marriage.
This disdain of the pretty fellow is often accounted for by amateur psychologists on the ground that women are anesthetic to beauty—that they lack the quick and delicate responsiveness of man. Nothing could be more absurd.
Women, in point of fact, commonly have a far keener aesthetic sense than men.
Show the passage
This disdain of the pretty fellow is often accounted for by amateur psychologists on the ground that women are anesthetic to beauty—that they lack the quick and delicate responsiveness of man. Nothing could be more absurd.
Women, in point of fact, commonly have a far keener aesthetic sense than men.
Beauty is more important to them; they give more thought to it; they crave more of it in their immediate surroundings. The average man, at least in England and America, takes a sort of bovine pride in his anaesthesia to the arts;
A truly beautiful man, indeed, is as rare as a truly beautiful piece of jewelry.
Show the passage
The truth is that women are resistant to so-called beauty in men for the simple and sufficient reason that such beauty is chiefly imaginary.
A truly beautiful man, indeed, is as rare as a truly beautiful piece of jewelry.
What men mistake for beauty in themselves is usually nothing save a certain hollow gaudiness, a revolting flashiness, the superficial splendour of a prancing animal.
9. Men as Aesthetes
But a woman is at once given away: she look like a dumbbell run over by an express train.
Show the passage
A man, save he be fat, i.e., of womanish contours, usually looks better in uniform than in mufti; the tight lines set off his figure.
But a woman is at once given away: she look like a dumbbell run over by an express train.
Below the neck by the bow and below the waist astern there are two masses that simply refuse to fit into a balanced composition.
But putting her into uniform is like stripping her. Instantly all her alleged beauty vanishes.
Show the passage
Viewed from the side, she presents an exaggerated S bisected by an imperfect straight line, and so she inevitably suggests a drunken dollar-mark. Her ordinary clothing cunningly conceals this fundamental imperfection. It swathes those impossible masses in draperies soothingly uncertain of outline.
But putting her into uniform is like stripping her. Instantly all her alleged beauty vanishes.
Moreover, it is extremely rare to find a woman who shows even the modest sightliness that her sex is theoretically capable of; it is only the rare beauty who is even tolerable.
10. The Process of Delusion
One would relatively speaking, almost caress him by spitting into his eye.
Show the passage
One would offend him far less by arguing that his wife is an idiot.
One would relatively speaking, almost caress him by spitting into his eye.
The ego of the male is simply unable to stomach such an affront. It is a weapon as discreditable as the poison of the Borgias.
The ego of the male is simply unable to stomach such an affront.
Show the passage
One would offend him far less by arguing that his wife is an idiot. One would relatively speaking, almost caress him by spitting into his eye.
The ego of the male is simply unable to stomach such an affront.
It is a weapon as discreditable as the poison of the Borgias.
11. Biological Considerations
The essential feminine machine is no better than the essential masculine machine; both are monuments to the maladroitness of a much over-praised Creator.
Show the passage
That is to say, it does not lie in any anatomical or physiological advantage.
The essential feminine machine is no better than the essential masculine machine; both are monuments to the maladroitness of a much over-praised Creator.
Women, it would seem, actually have smaller brains than men, though perhaps not in proportion to weight. Their nervous responses, if anything, are a bit duller than those of men; their muscular coordinations are surely no prompter.
12. Honour
He is honorable, perhaps, in gambling, for gambling is a mere vice, but it is quite unusual for him to be honorable in business, for business is bread and butter.
Show the passage
An animal fighting for its very existence uses all possible means of offence and defence, however foul. Even man, for all his boasting about honor, seldom displays it when he has anything of the first value at hazard.
He is honorable, perhaps, in gambling, for gambling is a mere vice, but it is quite unusual for him to be honorable in business, for business is bread and butter.
He is honorable (so long as the stake is trivial) in his sports, but he seldom permits honor to interfere with his perjuries in a lawsuit, or with hitting below the belt in any other sort of combat that is in earnest.
In the actual death-struggle he invariably bites.
Show the passage
Even here his so-called honor is little more than a form of playacting, both maudlin and dishonest.
In the actual death-struggle he invariably bites.
Perhaps one of the chief charms of woman lies precisely in the fact that they are dishonorable, i.e., that they are relatively uncivilized. In the midst of all the puerile repressions and inhibitions that hedge them round, they continue to show a gipsy spirit.
In the midst of all the puerile repressions and inhibitions that hedge them round, they continue to show a gipsy spirit.
Show the passage
Perhaps one of the chief charms of woman lies precisely in the fact that they are dishonorable, i.e., that they are relatively uncivilized.
In the midst of all the puerile repressions and inhibitions that hedge them round, they continue to show a gipsy spirit.
No genuine woman ever gives a hoot for law if law happens to stand in the way of her private interest. She is essentially an outlaw, a rebel, what H. G. Wells calls a nomad.
She is essentially an outlaw, a rebel, what H. G. Wells calls a nomad.
Show the passage
In the midst of all the puerile repressions and inhibitions that hedge them round, they continue to show a gipsy spirit. No genuine woman ever gives a hoot for law if law happens to stand in the way of her private interest.
She is essentially an outlaw, a rebel, what H. G. Wells calls a nomad.
The boons of civilization are so noisily cried up by sentimentalists that we are all apt to overlook its disadvantages. Intrinsically, it is a mere device for regimenting men. Its perfect symbol is the goose-step.
The boons of civilization are so noisily cried up by sentimentalists that we are all apt to overlook its disadvantages.
Show the passage
No genuine woman ever gives a hoot for law if law happens to stand in the way of her private interest. She is essentially an outlaw, a rebel, what H. G. Wells calls a nomad.
The boons of civilization are so noisily cried up by sentimentalists that we are all apt to overlook its disadvantages.
Intrinsically, it is a mere device for regimenting men. Its perfect symbol is the goose-step.
Intrinsically, it is a mere device for regimenting men. Its perfect symbol is the goose-step.
Show the passage
She is essentially an outlaw, a rebel, what H. G. Wells calls a nomad. The boons of civilization are so noisily cried up by sentimentalists that we are all apt to overlook its disadvantages.
Intrinsically, it is a mere device for regimenting men. Its perfect symbol is the goose-step.
The most civilized man is simply that man who has been most successful in caging and harnessing his honest and natural instincts-that is, the man who has done most cruel violence to his own ego in the interest of the commonweal.
The value of this commonweal is always overestimated. What is it at bottom?
Show the passage
The most civilized man is simply that man who has been most successful in caging and harnessing his honest and natural instincts-that is, the man who has done most cruel violence to his own ego in the interest of the commonweal.
The value of this commonweal is always overestimated. What is it at bottom?
Simply the greatest good to the greatest number—of petty rogues, ignoramuses and poltroons.
13. Women and the Emotions
Civilization, in fact, grows more and more maudlin and hysterical; especially under democracy it tends to degenerate into a mere combat of crazes; the whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by an endless series of hobgoblins, most of them imaginary.
Show the passage
Your true savage, reserved, dignified, and courteous, knows how to mask his feelings, even in the face of the most desperate assault upon them; your civilized man is forever yielding to them.
Civilization, in fact, grows more and more maudlin and hysterical; especially under democracy it tends to degenerate into a mere combat of crazes; the whole aim of practical politics is to keep the populace alarmed (and hence clamorous to be led to safety) by an endless series of hobgoblins, most of them imaginary.
Wars are no longer waged by the will of superior men, capable of judging dispassionately and intelligently the causes behind them and the effects flowing out of them. They are now begun by first throwing a mob into a panic;
15. Mythical Anthropophagi
The man-hating woman, like the cold woman, is largely imaginary.
Show the passage
The man-hating woman, like the cold woman, is largely imaginary.
One often encounters references to her in literature, but who has ever met her in real life? As for me, I doubt that such a monster has ever actually existed.
19. The Actual Husband
The average man is an almost incredible popinjay; he can think of himself only as at the centre of situations.
Show the passage
… the devices described, take refuge behind the sour grapes doctrine that they have never tried, and the latter, having fallen victims, sooth their egoism by arrogating the whole agency to themselves, thus giving it a specious appearance of the volitional, and even of the audacious.
The average man is an almost incredible popinjay; he can think of himself only as at the centre of situations.
All the sordid transactions of his life appear to him, and are depicted in his accounts of them, as feats, successes, proofs of his acumen.
The American is chivalrous for the simple reason that the initiative is not in his hands. His chivalry is really a sort of coquetry.
Show the passage
This is the explanation of the fact that a Frenchman, say, is habitually enterprising in amour, and hence bold and often offensive, whereas an American is what is called chivalrous.
The American is chivalrous for the simple reason that the initiative is not in his hands. His chivalry is really a sort of coquetry.
22. Compulsory Marriage
In the same way, I have no doubt, the majority of foxes would object to choosing lots to determine the victim of a projected fox-hunt. They prefer to take their chances with the dogs.
Show the passage
But that chance has a sugarcoating; it is swathed in egoistic illusion; it shows less stark and intolerable chanciness, so to speak, than the bald hazard of the die. Thus men prefer it, and shrink from the other.
In the same way, I have no doubt, the majority of foxes would object to choosing lots to determine the victim of a projected fox-hunt. They prefer to take their chances with the dogs.
24. Intermezzo on Monogamy
It makes passion formal and uninspiring, and so gradually kills it.
Show the passage
Monogamy accomplishes this, not by producing satiety, but by destroying appetite.
It makes passion formal and uninspiring, and so gradually kills it.
The advocates of monogamy, deceived by its moral overtones, fail to get all the advantage out of it that is in it. Consider, for example, the important moral business of safeguarding the virtue of the unmarried—that is, of the still passionate.
Monogamy, in brief, kills passion—and passion is the most dangerous of all the surviving enemies to what we call civilization, which is based upon order, decorum, restraint, formality, industry, regimentation.
Show the passage
civilized men are in favour of it because they find that it works. And why does it work? Because it is the most effective of all available antidotes to the alarms and terrors of passion.
Monogamy, in brief, kills passion—and passion is the most dangerous of all the surviving enemies to what we call civilization, which is based upon order, decorum, restraint, formality, industry, regimentation.
The civilized man—the ideal civilized man—is simply one who never sacrifices the common security to his private passions.
26. Disparate Unions
The universe seems to be in a conspiracy to encourage the endless reproduction of peasants and Socialists, but a subtle and mysterious opposition stands eternally against the reproduction of philosophers.
Show the passage
All animal breeders know how difficult it is to maintain a fine strain.
The universe seems to be in a conspiracy to encourage the endless reproduction of peasants and Socialists, but a subtle and mysterious opposition stands eternally against the reproduction of philosophers.
Per corollary, it is notorious that women of merit frequently marry second-rate men, and bear them children, thus aiding in the war upon progress.
27. The Charm of Mystery
The world invariably suspects the worst.
Show the passage
One lies in its costliness: the average couple cannot afford a double establishment, even temporarily. The other lies in the fact that it inevitably arouses the envy and ill-nature of those who cannot adopt it, and so causes a gabbling of scandal.
The world invariably suspects the worst.
Let man and wife separate to save their happiness from suffocation in the kitchen, the dining room and the connubial chamber, and it will immediately conclude that the corpse is already laid out in the drawing-room.
32. The Woman Voter
Reform, as usual, mistakes the fish for the fly.
Show the passage
… shave the heads of all the pretty girls in the world, and pluck out their eyebrows, and pull their teeth, and put them in khaki, and forbid them to wriggle on dance-floors, or to wear scents, or to use lip-sticks, or to roll their eyes.
Reform, as usual, mistakes the fish for the fly.
Men will keep on pursuing women until hell freezes over, and women will keep luring them on.
Show the passage
Fortunately for the human race, the campaigns of these indignant viragoes will come to naught.
Men will keep on pursuing women until hell freezes over, and women will keep luring them on.
If the latter enterprise were abandoned, in fact, the whole game of love would play out, for not many men take any notice of women spontaneously.
33. A Glance Into the Future
What starts a male meeting to snuffling and trembling most violently is precisely the thing that would cause a female meeting to sniff.
Show the passage
It is a peculiarity of women that they are not easily set off by such alarms, that they do not fall readily into such facile tumults and phobias.
What starts a male meeting to snuffling and trembling most violently is precisely the thing that would cause a female meeting to sniff.
What we need, to ward off mobocracy and safeguard a civilized form of government, is more of this sniffing.
It is a peculiarity of women that they are not easily set off by such alarms, that they do not fall readily into such facile tumults and phobias.
Show the passage
… States, the most terrible existing democratic state, have scarcely had a political campaign that was not based upon some preposterous fear—first of slavery and then of the manumitted slave, first of capitalism and then of communism, first of the old and then of the novel.
It is a peculiarity of women that they are not easily set off by such alarms, that they do not fall readily into such facile tumults and phobias.
What starts a male meeting to snuffling and trembling most violently is precisely the thing that would cause a female meeting to sniff. What we need, to ward off mobocracy and safeguard a civilized form of government, is more of this sniffing.
35. A Mythical Dare-Devil
First he sees difficulty, then he sees the danger, then he sees wrong.
Show the passage
… rouged, her eyelashes drooping provokingly—the moment such an abandoned wench has at him, and his lack of ready funds begins to conspire with his lack of courage to assault and wobble him—at that precise moment his conscience flares into function, and so finishes his business.
First he sees difficulty, then he sees the danger, then he sees wrong.
The result is that he slinks off in trepidation, and another vampire is baffled of her prey.
A man, remember, is not a being in vacuo; he is the fruit and slave of the environment that bathes him.
Show the passage
It may be indistinguishable, at times, from the mere fear that someone may be looking. It may be shot through with hypocrisy, stupidity, play-acting. But nevertheless, as consciences go in Christendom, it is genuinely entitled to the name—and it is always in action.
A man, remember, is not a being in vacuo; he is the fruit and slave of the environment that bathes him.
One cannot enter the House of Commons, the United States Senate, or a prison for felons without becoming, in some measure, a rascal. One cannot fall overboard without shipping water. One cannot pass through a modern university without carrying away scars.
One cannot fall overboard without shipping water.
Show the passage
A man, remember, is not a being in vacuo; he is the fruit and slave of the environment that bathes him. One cannot enter the House of Commons, the United States Senate, or a prison for felons without becoming, in some measure, a rascal.
One cannot fall overboard without shipping water.
One cannot pass through a modern university without carrying away scars.
One cannot pass through a modern university without carrying away scars.
Show the passage
he is the fruit and slave of the environment that bathes him. One cannot enter the House of Commons, the United States Senate, or a prison for felons without becoming, in some measure, a rascal. One cannot fall overboard without shipping water.
One cannot pass through a modern university without carrying away scars.
And by the same token one cannot live and have one’s being in a modern democratic state, year in and year out, without falling, to some extent at least, under that moral obsession which is the hall-mark of the mob-man set free.
37. Women as Martyrs
Man is always looking for someone to boast to; woman is always looking for a shoulder to put her head on.
Show the passage
he also enjoys helping her dry her tears. The result is the vast pretence that characterizes the relations of the sexes under civilization—the double pretence of man’s cunning and autonomy and of woman’s dependence and deference.
Man is always looking for someone to boast to; woman is always looking for a shoulder to put her head on.
This feminine affectation, of course, has gradually taken on the force of a fixed habit, and so it has got a certain support, by a familiar process of self-delusion, in reality. The civilized woman inherits that habit as she inherits her cunning.
This fact probably explains many mysterious divorces: the husband was not too bad, but too good.
Show the passage
Let a woman have a husband whose conduct is not reasonably open to question, and she will invent mythical offences to make him bearable. And if her invention fails she will be plunged into the utmost misery and humiliation.
This fact probably explains many mysterious divorces: the husband was not too bad, but too good.
For public opinion among women, remember, does not favour the woman who is full of a placid contentment and has no masculine torts to report;
The most esteemed woman gossip is the one with the longest and most various repertoire of complaints.
Show the passage
A man, speaking of his wife to other men, always praises her extravagantly. Boasting about her soothes his vanity; he likes to stir up the envy of his fellows. But when two women talk of their husbands it is mainly atrocities that they describe.
The most esteemed woman gossip is the one with the longest and most various repertoire of complaints.
This yearning for martyrdom explains one of the commonly noted characters of women: their eager flair for bearing physical pain. As we have seen, they have actually a good deal less endurance than men; massive injuries shock them more severely and kill them more quickly.
40. Piety as a Social Habit
Women go to church for the same reason that farmers and convicts go to church.
Show the passage
In the course of a life largely devoted to the study of pietistic phenomena, I have never met a single woman who cared an authentic damn for the actual heathen. The attraction in their salvation is always almost purely social.
Women go to church for the same reason that farmers and convicts go to church.
Finally, there is the aesthetic lure. Religion, in most parts of Christendom, holds out the only bait of beauty that the inhabitants are ever cognizant of.
It offers music, dim lights, relatively ambitious architecture, eloquence, formality and mystery, the caressing meaninglessness that is at the heart of poetry.
Show the passage
Finally, there is the aesthetic lure. Religion, in most parts of Christendom, holds out the only bait of beauty that the inhabitants are ever cognizant of.
It offers music, dim lights, relatively ambitious architecture, eloquence, formality and mystery, the caressing meaninglessness that is at the heart of poetry.
Women are far more responsive to such things than men, who are ordinarily quite as devoid of aesthetic sensitiveness as so many oxen. The attitude of the typical man toward beauty in its various forms is, in fact, an attitude of suspicion and hostility.
Religion, in most parts of Christendom, holds out the only bait of beauty that the inhabitants are ever cognizant of.
Show the passage
Finally, there is the aesthetic lure.
Religion, in most parts of Christendom, holds out the only bait of beauty that the inhabitants are ever cognizant of.
It offers music, dim lights, relatively ambitious architecture, eloquence, formality and mystery, the caressing meaninglessness that is at the heart of poetry. Women are far more responsive to such things than men, who are ordinarily quite as devoid of aesthetic sensitiveness as so many oxen.
42. The Transvaluation of Values
The old order changeth and giveth place to the new.
Show the passage
… attractive to the better sort of men, and so it is not uncommon for one of them to find herself voluntarily sought in marriage, without any preliminary scheming by herself—surely an experience that very few ordinary women ever enjoy, save perhaps in dreams or delirium.
The old order changeth and giveth place to the new.
Among the women’s clubs and in the women’s colleges, I have no doubt, there is still much debate of the old and silly question: Are platonic relations possible between the sexes? In other words, is friendship possible without sex?
In other words, is friendship possible without sex? Many a woman of the new order dismisses the problem with another question: Why without sex?
Show the passage
The old order changeth and giveth place to the new. Among the women’s clubs and in the women’s colleges, I have no doubt, there is still much debate of the old and silly question: Are platonic relations possible between the sexes?
In other words, is friendship possible without sex? Many a woman of the new order dismisses the problem with another question: Why without sex?
With the decay of the ancient concept of women as property there must come inevitably a reconsideration of the whole sex question, and out of that reconsideration there must come a revision of the mediaeval penalties which now punish the slightest frivolity in the female.
Read In Defense of Women free
The whole book is free in Doomreader, as short posts you scroll like a feed, with your place kept. Or download the EPUB.